Key Highlights
- An SEO specialist looks after your website and builds plans to bring your business more clients through search.
- AEO, or answer engine optimisation, is the newer work of getting your business named in answers from AI tools such as ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews. AEO builds on SEO, so the best hire is an SEO specialist with AEO experience.
- AI tools let you do much of the SEO work yourself, such as research, writing and reporting. The strategy and the process behind it need a specialist’s judgement.
- A good specialist gives clear answers about their previous experience, ownership of your domain (your website address) and accounts, the work they will deliver, and the KPIs, which are the numbers, such as enquiries, that measure the results.
Search results now include AI-generated answers, such as Google AI Overviews, and AI tools such as ChatGPT recommend businesses by name when a customer asks for one. Ranking on the first page of Google has also become harder, which makes SEO more important for any business that wants to appear when someone searches for what it sells.
Hiring an SEO specialist is difficult too. Experienced specialists are in short supply, and people with little experience call themselves SEO specialists and can damage the rankings a website already has.
This guide covers what an SEO specialist does, how SEO and AEO fit together, where AI tools help, and the questions that separate experienced specialists from the rest.
What does an SEO specialist do?
An SEO specialist is a person who improves a website so it appears higher in Google and in AI-generated answers for the searches a business’s customers make. The work follows an SEO marketing strategy, which roughly covers seven areas:
- Keyword research: The specialist finds the searches your customers type and chooses the ones worth targeting, based on search volume and competition.
- On-page optimisation: The specialist rewrites page titles, headings, meta descriptions and internal links so each page matches one search topic.
- Technical SEO: The specialist fixes crawling, indexing, page speed, mobile layout and structured data problems that stop pages from appearing in Google. The technical SEO checklist lists these checks.
- Content: The specialist plans pages and articles that answer customer questions, and updates older pages that have gone out of date.
- Local SEO: For a business that serves a suburb or city, the specialist manages the Google Business Profile, customer reviews and local listings.
- Link building: The specialist earns links and mentions from other reputable websites, such as industry bodies, suppliers and publications. Our guide covers link building and brand building for Australian SMEs in a separate article.
- Reporting: The specialist tracks rankings, clicks and enquiries in Google Search Console and Google Analytics and reports them on a regular schedule.
Should your business hire an SEO specialist?
An SEO specialist is worth hiring when your website is supposed to bring in enquiries and doesn’t, or used to and stopped. The specialist works out why your pages don’t appear in Google for the services you want more work in, fixes the cause, and reports the result as enquiries you can count.
Hire one if any of these apply:
- The website is a main source of enquiries or sales.
- Competitors appear above the business for the searches its customers use.
- Nobody on the team has several hours a week to spend on SEO.
- Pages have dropped out of Google after a website redesign or platform migration.
Should you hire an SEO specialist or an AEO specialist?
AEO, or answer engine optimisation, is the work of getting your business named and cited in answers from AI tools such as Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT and Perplexity. When a customer asks one of these tools about your service, AEO is what puts your business in the answer. The AEO work covers:
- Writing a short, direct answer to each main customer question near the top of the page, in plain text.
- Using question-style headings and FAQ sections that match how customers phrase their questions.
- Publishing specific facts, prices where possible, and cited sources that an AI tool can quote accurately.
- Keeping business details consistent across your website, Google Business Profile and directories, and earning mentions on other reputable websites.
- Tracking where AI answers mention your business for its main customer questions.
AEO builds on SEO. An AI tool can cite only a page it can crawl and read, so the SEO basics come first. AEO work on a site with weak SEO has little to build on, so an AEO-only provider is the wrong hire.
SEO specialists and agencies are adding AEO to their services, and many are still building that experience. A prospective specialist’s AEO track record is worth checking: examples of client businesses that now appear in AI answers, and how the specialist tracks those mentions.
Can you do SEO yourself with AI tools?
AI helps with SEO, and we use it throughout our own SEO work. SEO still takes a strategy built on data and repeated testing, which a prompt cannot supply. A business owner can use AI tools to put a basic SEO foundation in place at each phase:
- Research: AI tools group keywords and suggest topics.
- Build: AI tools generate page layouts, code and site structure for a new website.
- Content: AI tools draft page copy, meta descriptions and FAQ answers.
- Tracking: AI tools summarise Google Search Console and Google Analytics reports and flag changes.
Every phase still needs a specialist’s judgement. A specialist chooses the keywords worth targeting for the business, checks AI drafts for accuracy, selects the pages to publish, and traces a ranking change to the edit that caused it. SEO results come from changing one thing, measuring it in the data and adjusting, and that cycle runs for months. An AI tool also has no facts, examples or opinions from your business unless someone supplies them.
Unchecked AI output carries two risks. Google’s March 2024 core update introduced a spam policy against scaled content abuse, which covers large numbers of pages made mainly to rank, whether automation, people or both produced them. In our experience, websites that published mass-produced AI content lost rankings after Google’s updates. Technical changes, such as redirects after a migration, crawl settings and structured data, alter the site itself, and a mistake can remove pages from Google.
How to hire an SEO specialist
Once you have shortlisted a few agencies or candidates, these questions show what each of them has done. A good specialist answers in plain language and backs the answer with examples.
1. Which businesses like mine have you worked with, and what happened to their enquiries?
A specialist who can show enquiries before and after from a business in your industry or market has done this work somewhere similar, and past clients can confirm it in a short reference call.
2. What would you fix first on my website?
A specialist who has looked at your site names specific things, such as a service with no page of its own, missing tracking or slow pages. An answer that would suit any website means the specialist is working from a template.
3. How long until I see results, and can you guarantee a ranking?
SEO builds over months, and clicks from search rise before enquiries do. A credible answer gives a range and explains what moves first. No specialist controls search results, so a specialist who guarantees a number one ranking is promising something outside their control.
4. What will your report show?
A report with enquiries from search and the cost of each enquiry lets you compare SEO with Google Ads and your other marketing, and judge it against the monthly target you set.
5. Who owns the accounts and the content, and what happens if we stop?
Your domain, hosting, Google Analytics, Search Console and Google Business Profile accounts, and your website content, belong in your business’s name. When the specialist holds the logins, leaving means losing your data and history. The contract should state the minimum term and the notice period.
6. How do you use AI, and who checks it?
AI makes research, drafting and reporting faster, and websites that publish mass-produced AI pages have lost rankings. A good specialist uses AI for speed and has a person check the facts and approve each page before it is published.
7. What is your experience with AEO?
Customers now get answers from AI tools such as ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews, and SEO specialists are adding AEO to their services. Experience varies, so ask for clients that now appear in AI answers and the method the specialist uses to track them. AEO builds on SEO, so the specialist should be strong at core SEO as well.
How to know your SEO is working
Test any team or specialist, then monitor your business outcomes. Enquiries, bookings and sales from search show whether your SEO is working.
Digital Treasury is an experienced agency with SEO at the core of its services. Our team of SEO specialists has run SEO marketing successfully for businesses across Australia. If you want an SEO specialist who can win more customers for your business, we have a team focused on your growth. Book a demo.





